
Opening, Geneviève Fraisse
Moral chronicle ( summary), Alain Vergnioux (University of Caen)
To ask the school the question of its rhythms, raises the
question of powering the educational time in a goal of control and
efficiency of its activities. While opposing it the metaphor of
the swing, the author wants to show that the idea of rhythm
doesn't mean a thing, but in rupture and invention - achieved by
and for individuals.
Notion : The Parity ( summary), Pierre Statius (University of Franche-Comté)
The debate on the parity throws into relief the
contradiction between the universal definition of manhood and the
account of the sexual difference. How to rectify the masculine
hegemony without falling into the communautarian fragmentation ?
The author shows that the question sends back to two conceptions
of the citizenship, privileging one the association of various
concrete individuals, the other the integration of equal
individuals to an abstract model.
Report: Mixity
Introduction, Laurence Cornu (IUFM Poitou-Charentes)
Coeducation : social, ethical and political issues ( summary), Nicole Mosconi (University Paris X)
Coeducation was one of the major transformations of the
education system in this century. A major issue is whether it
leads to a better understanding between the sexes or rather brings
them into conflict. The French Third Republic continued the
tradition of separate schools for the sexes that it inherited from
the Church, in preference to the American 'coeducational'
system. Coeducation was introduced in stages to France only after
the Second World War, following women's emancipation. However,
whereas the debate at the beginning of the century between the
proponents and adversaries of coeducation was based on
preconceived socio-political ideas, the late introduction of
coeducation was made law without any educational goal or explicit
debate. For this reason pernicious inequalities still persist and
call not for idealism but for a debate on the ethical and
political measures that need to be taken to make equal
opportunities between boys and girls a reality.
Memories of before ( summary)
Psychoanalytic experience and thought is used in this
paper to provide an anamnesis that searches for meaning in the
midst of 'perceptible' memories. While separate high schools for
girls leaves the terrain of sexuality fallow and, at the
initiation of the latent phase, contributes to 'epistemophilia',
during adolescence this terrain is left 'uncultivated'. Separate
schools lead to an idealisation of the opposite sex which is
doomed to bitter disillusionment. Today we know that learning
together doesn't prevent learning as such. Coeducation provides
'real' companionship but also engenders other effects. With or
without coeducation, the relationships between the sexes must be
constructed.
Adolescence ( summary), Dominique Ottavi (IUFM of Versailles)
Adolescence is a problem period both in educational terms
and for researchers trying to understand it. At a time when
Freudian thought was being developed, Granville Stanley Hall and
his co-workers at Clarke University were working in this field and
put forward the concept of genetic psychology. According to this
theory, adolescence is the time when childhood comes to an end,
the individual enters into the flow of the wider world of humanity
as a whole and discovers spirituality. It is a time of opening up
and also one of conversions. Female puberty is thus described as a
woman's discovery of her physical and spiritual place in the
'chain of life', which transcends the individual.
Engendering sex ( summary), Anne-Marie Drouin-Hans (University of Bourgogne)
Rousseau, in Emile, gave roles to Emile and Sophie in the
belief that the human race was a single entity. The shortcomings
of this search for characteristics, the conclusions of which shock
our modern way of thinking, can in fact be found in certain
currents of contemporary feminist thought. Thus the use of the
word gender since the 1970's, which is supposed to transcend the
biological determinism of the term sex, has in fact numerous
ambiguities that derive from the difficulty in conceptualising
both universality and difference and to the aporia according to
which we cannot live without images - that turn out to be
false. 'Gender' doesn't exist as such but has to be constructed,
painstakingly and through role playing.
Between nature and artefact : rediscovering mixed
society ( summary), Bernadette Bensaude Vincent (Université Paris X)
Publicity images notwithstanding, nothing is pure in
nature. Mixing and blending gives rise to order - in its oldest
sense, meaning the opposite of chaos - and innovation. Whether
conceived of as geometrical figures or a qualitative explanation,
for the ancient Greeks the cosmos was considered to be an infinite
variety of harmonious combinations between a finite number of
elements. While the Greek city was always based on exclusion, Rome
was founded on heterogeneity. This philosophy is reflected in
contemporary composite materials. Developing them requires that
heterogeneous groups work together and this 'multi-material'
culture could be an inspiration for the concept of a composite
society, a transposition to the social context of the
possibilities of mixing.
From gender metaphysics to a frontier strategy ( summary), Brigitte Frelat-Kahn (IUFM of Paris)
Within the concept of a mixed society there are elements
of both a hierarchical and an egalitarian system. According to
entitative metaphysics, the fact that both sexes belong to the
human race doesn't exclude the commensurate and hierarchical
differentiation of gender. With the demands for equality of the
sexes, universality dissolves as the boundaries fade. Mixed
society becomes a question of plurality, of relationships, of
exploring the boundaries that constitute the individual, of
competition that requires compromise. These are questions of
tolerance rather than complementarity.
A principle of uncertainty. Reflections on democracy and
mixed society ( summary), Pierre-Damien Huyghe (University Paris I)
Plato criticised democracy on the grounds that it was
based on desire and so was without limitations. According to this,
desire and equality are incompatible. The question posed is indeed
how to find a modus vivendi between subjects considered equal but
with contradictory desires ? A mixed society exists precisely when
a desire (an incommensurable singularity) can be linked to another
in a way that does not involve power. A mixed society allows a
peaceful interaction between desires. It is therefore not an ideal
but a fact, the concrete political fact par excellence - a
principle of uncertainty, not a practicality, a tissue, a tension
within a given gender. A mixed society does not obey an
apportionment logic. Its very structure is what prevents an
identity being assigned to an individual.
Studies : The De magistro of St Augustin and models of
teaching ( summary), Jean-Marc Lamarre (IUFM of Pays de Loire)
The number 14 of the magazine proposed an article of
Israel Scheffler in which the American philosopher brought back
questioning on the teaching to three main : what way of teaching
shall I aim to succeed ? In what consists such a teaching indeed ?
What could I make so that it succeeded ? Questions that he dealt
with through the three figures of Locke, Augustin and
Kant. Jean-Marc Lamarre answers him today on his interpretation of
the De magistro, particularly upon the question of the
language.
Correspondence : About the identity of educational theory ( summary), Maria Eugénia Motta Falco (University of Lisboa)
The identity of educational theory is problematical on
account of having to be a theory of educational action. The
purpose of this paper is to identify the specific knowledge for
education. The solution is an identity for educational theory in
the diversity of appropriate meanings for a theory of education
which can be achieved through complex and contextual
researches.
|